Showing posts with label Colonialism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Colonialism. Show all posts

Sunday, 13 September 2026

The Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford, England, has agreed to return the remains of 39 Naga ancestors to India.

The Pitt Rivers Museum of the University of Oxford has agreed to return the remains of 39 Naga ancestors to Nagaland, India, according to a press release issued by the museum. This repatriation has come about as a result of dialogues between the museum and the Forum for Naga Reconciliation, an umbrella organisation representing the rights of the Naga people in Nagaland and neighbouring Indian states, as well as northern Myanmar. 

The Pitt Rivers Museum holds the world's largest collection of Naga material, much of it collected by John Henry Hutton and James Philip Mills, two British colonial officials, ethnographers, and anthropologists who worked in the area during the first half of the twentieth century. Both men amassed large collections of ethnographic materials during their time in India, much of it seized during punitive military exhibitions.

During these expeditions preserved skulls kept by the peoples of Nagaland were particularly sought after. Naga communities typically had a house, cave or rockshelter in which many such skulls were stored. The British colonial authorities interpreted these as trophies associated with headhunting, something which demonstrated the superiority of British culture, and therefore the importance of the British imperial project in bringing civilisation to the world.

While there may have been some headhunting in Nagaland, the origin of the majority of these skulls derives from the traditional burial practices of the Naga people. These varied from community to community, although the most common form appears to have been a form of platform burial, in which the body was wrapped in cloth and placed on a raised Bamboo platform called a machang at the edge of the village, where it was typically consumed by Animals. The skull of the deceased was removed and cleaned before placing it in a sacred cave, called a Khulo Apshang (or if this was not available, a specially built house called a Lochem), along with those of other ancestors. Notably, not everyone could have their skull placed in a sacred place; persons who died as a result of violence, accidents, or diseases perceived as unclean (such as leprosy) were denied such funerary rights and had separate burial customs. 

Human skulls in a rock shelter in Nagaland. Sumi (2024).

It is also possible that some skulls were taken directly by British soldiers or adventurers; 'native' skulls were highly sought after by both museums and private collectors in Europe, seen as natural history specimens which could be used to demonstrate theories about evolution and European superiority fashionable at the time (this would have required a degree of creativity, as modern archaeologists cannot reliably differentiate European from non-European skulls based upon morphological examination).

Today the Pitt Rivers Museum holds approximately 6500 items identified as being of Naga origin. Of these 219 are listed as being Human remains; 39 identifiable body parts, predominantly skulls but also including a finger and a piece of skin with hair, and 178 artefacts which may contain Human hair. It is the 39 body elements which the museum is currently planning to return to Nagaland.

Until 2020, many skulls from the Nagaland collection were on display in the Pitt Rivers Museum, but in that year the decision was taken to remove them from public viewing. The publicity raised by this event attracted the attention of Dolly Kikon, a member of the Lotha-Naga community, and professor of anthropology at the University of California, Santa Cruz, and a member of the Forum for Naga Reconciliation. Kikon then contacted  Laura Van Broekhoven, the director of the Pitt Rivers Museum, beginning the dialogue which has led to the planned return of the items.

Professor Dolly Kikon of the University of California Santa Cruz. Dolly Kikon.

During the Covid 19 pandemic, the Forum for Naga Reconciliation formed a Recover, Restore, and Decolonise team, under the leadership of Dolly Kikon and Arkotong Longkumer, who comes from Kohima in Nagaland and is a professor of anthropology at the University of Edinburgh. This group arranged for a visit to the Pitt Rivers Museum by a Naga delegation including leaders and elders of several Naga tribe Hohos (councils), together with members of the Forum for Naga Reconciliation and Forum for Naga Reconciliation, in June 2025.

Dolly Kikon with Phyobemo Ngully, a member Forum for Naga Reconciliation and other guests at the closing reception on 13 June 2025 at the Pitt Rivers Museum, University of Oxford. A Naga Delegation comprising of leaders from several Naga Tribe Hohos, members of the Forum for Naga Reconciliation and the Recover Restore and Decolonise team were hosted by Pitt Rivers Museum from 8 June-14 June 2025 to explore a pathway for the return and future care of Naga ancestral Human remains. Sanen Kichu/Recover Restore and Decolonise.

As a result of this visit, the Pitt Rivers Museum proposed the return of the 39 identifiable body parts in its Naga collection, one of which was rejected due to uncertainty about its provenance (i.e. it was uncertain whether it actually came from Nagaland), and the Naga delegation produced the Naga-Oxford Declaration on Repatriation, which reads:

  • We are grateful to our ancestors for being a testament and silently proclaiming the stories of our people.
  • We are sorry that it has taken us several decades but we are here now to reclaim and return you to the homelands from where you were taken.
  • We are committed to the process of your return from museums.
  • We acknowledge that this Repatriation process is towards the healing and wholeness of the Naga people.
  • As Nagas, we do so in a united voice, with mutual respect and consensus and to offer you a dignified rest, establishing a Naga monument of healing and peace for all generations, symbolising the oneness of the Nagas.
  • We extend our solidarity to fellow Indigenous Peoples across the world who seek to undertake a similar journey of repatriation in the hope of bringing decolonisation, justice and peace, not just for ourselves but for humanity.
Members of the Naga delegation view the relics on display at the Pitt Rivers Museum. Pitt Rivers Museum.

Because it is uncertain where about in Nagaland many of the remains come from, the Recover, Restore, and Decolonise team plan to construct a joint memorial resting place for the ancestors, intended as a place of healing and peace for all generations and as a symbol of the oneness of the Naga. Once this has been done, the plan is for the Naga delegation to return to the Pitt Rivers Museum for a handover ceremony, after which they will accompany the ancestors on their journey home.

See also...

Wednesday, 3 September 2025

France returns skull of King Toera of Menabé to Madagascar.

The head of King Toera (or Itoera) of Menabé, a former kingdom in the west of Madagascar, betweem the Mangoky and Manambalo rivers, has been returned to the island by France. The former king was captured in battle following a rebellion against the French government of Madagascar in 1897, and was subsequently beheaded along with two of his supporters. The three heads were then taken to Paris, where they were placed in the collection of the Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle as 'anthropological specimens'.

Harea Georges Kamamy, the current King of Menabé, carrying his ancestors skull following a ceremony at the French Ministry of Culture on 27 August 2025. Stéphane du Sakutin/AFP.

The Kingdom of Menabé was formed in about 1540 by Adriamandazoala, who led a group of Sakalava people from the south of the island on a migration into the area (one of two kingdoms in the west of Madagascar formed by migrating Sakalava people at about this time, along with Boina, to the north of the Manambalo River. The kingdom grew under notable rulers such as Andriandahifotsy, (died 1685) and Andriandrainarivo (died 1727), but was incorporated into a unified Kingdom of Madagascar by Radama I in 1820 (although sporadic uprisings would occur until 1840 when Queen Ranavalona I placed garrisons in all the major towns of  Menabé and moved farmers into the region from other regions of Madagascar to dilute loyalty to the Menabé kings (who were nevertheless able to keep their titles, albeit as rulers of a subordinate kingdom).

In 1883 France invaded Madagascar, with fighting continuing till 1886, when a treaty was signed granting the French control of the port of Diego-Suarez (now Antsiranana) as well as the right to determine Malagasy foreign policy, making the island an effective (but not official) French protectorate. In 1894 France launched a second invasion, marching upon the capital, Antananarivo, which fell in September 1895, following a brief shelling by French artillery.  On 1 October 1895 Queen Ranavalona III signed a treaty making Madagascar an official protectorate of France. 

In 1897, following an uprising in central Madagascar, the Malagasy monarchy was abolished and Queen Ranavalona III was exiled to Réunion, never to return. The French military commander, Joseph Gallieni. King Toera did not take part in this initial rebellion, but when direct rule by France was declared, he joined the rebellion, putting together an army of 10 000 warriors armed with riffles. An expedition to Menabé was launched under the French General Augustin Gérard, who reached the Menabé capitol, Ambiky on 30 August 1987, which, like Antananarivo before it, fell after a short artillery bombardment. 

King Toera was captured and beheaded along with two of his senior advisers. Their heads were subsequently shipped to France and placed in the anthropological collection of the Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle. During the entire campaign only two French casualties were recorded, both soldiers from the Tirailleurs Sénégalais (a West African regiment that did not recruit exclusively from Senegal).

More than 20 000 sets of Human remains are still held in the collection of the Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle, including hundreds more from Madagascar, with collections also held by other French museums and universities. Similar collections are held by institutes in other countries in Europe, as well as other parts of the world. 

In 2023 France changed its laws on the ownership of such remains, in order to allow their return to countries from which they were obtained, this having become a sticking point in relations with many nations around the world. The return of the skulls of King Toera and his advisers is the first such repatriation under the new law.

DNA tests carried out at the Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle proved unable to determine which of the skulls belonged to King Toera, although they were able to determine that they did belong to people of Sakalava origin, so an identification was carried out by a Sakalava spirit medium. The three skulls were handed over in a ceremony in Paris on 27 August 2025, and reached Antananarivo on 1 September. From here they are being taken overland to Menabé, where they will be buried.

The three skulls arriving in Antananarivo on 1 September 2025. Mamyrael/AFP.

See also...