Showing posts with label South Africa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label South Africa. Show all posts

Wednesday, 15 April 2026

South Africa returns Chapungu Bird and Human remains to Zimbabwe.

Iziko Museums of South Africa have returned a Chapungu Bird taken from the Great Zimbabwe site in Zimbabwe and eight sets of Human remains to representatives of the Government of Zimbabwe at a ceremony held in Cape Town on 14 April 2026. All were removed from sites within Zimbabwe during the nineteenth century and found their way into the collection of the museums. The timing of the restoration follows a directive from South African President Cyril Ramaphosa that the items should be returned before the Zimbabwean Independence Day Celebrations on 18 April, part of a broader program by South African museums which aims to return objects and remains removed during the colonial era to the countries and communities from which they were taken.

The Chapungu Bird in the collection of the Iziko South African Museum in Cape Town on 13 April 2026, before its repatriation to Zimbabwe. ZimLive.

The Chapungu Bird is one of eight such statues removed from the site by British adventurers in the nineteenth century. Each is made from a dark grey/green soapstone (a soft metamorphic rock) and stands 33 cm high. The statues formerly stood on pedestals about a metre high at the Great Zimbabwe site, and have been taken as a national symbol by the modern state of Zimbabwe, appearing on the national flag as well as coins and banknotes. The statue from Cape Town is the last to be returned to Zimbabwe, which has been seeking their restitution since independence in 1980.

As well as the Chapungu Bird, Iziko South African Museums has returned eight sets of Human remains which were removed from sites in Zimbabwe during the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The remains are thought to have come from different communities around Zimbabwe, although full details have not been made available. One set of remains is thought to have belonged to a chief, and to have been exhumed and taken to South Africa in 1910. Another has been reported as a man murdered following accusations of witchcraft. All are known to have been taken from graves without the permission of their families of communities, and to have been retained at the museum as scientific specimens.

The remains of eight individuals taken from Zimbabwe during the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, and returned by Iziko Museums South Africa on 14 April 2026. ZimLive.

See also...





Tuesday, 23 December 2025

The deep roots of social inequality in South Africa's Cape Colony.

Thirty one years after the end of the Apartheid system, the World Bank still rates South Africa to be the most unequal country on Earth, with a Gini Index of 0.63, four points ahead of the second-placed nation, Namibia (the Gini Index measures inequality from 0.00 to 1.00, where 0.00 represents all wealth being distributed equally among the population, and 1.00 represents a single person owning everything within a nation). It has been calculated that the richest 1% of the South African population own 55% of the country's wealth, while the top 10% own more than 85%. Thus wealth inequality within South Africa is equal to that of the entire globe.

Most modern research into inequality in South Africa concentrates on the post-Apartheid era, although it is generally accepted that the country's long history of racial discrimination and political repression is linked to the current state of inequality. However, the question of when this inequality first arose has not really been addressed by historians.

In a paper published in the South African Journal of Science on 26 November 2025, Johan Fourie of the Laboratory for the Economics of Africa’s Past at Stellenbosch University presents the results of a study in which he examined historical records from the Dutch Cape Colony of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries and the British Cape Colony of the early nineteenth century, in order to attempt to understand the origins of the severe inequality seen in South Africa today.

Fourie notes that the Cape Colony was a deeply unequal place, even compared to modern South Africa. There were three distinct populations present, European settlers, enslaved people, and the indigenous Khoesan population (note, this is not always considered to be an acceptable name for this group, as it is linked to a history of persecution and discrimination, however, no term is universally deemed acceptable, and it is the term used by Fourie within his study). The economic inequality between these three groups, was predictably stark, but even within these groups inequality was very high.

Most societies in the developed world became steadily more equal in the decades after the Second World War, however, whilst this continued for the remainder of the twentieth century in continental Europe and Japan, the countries of the English-speaking word have become increasingly unequal since the 1970s, a pattern which has been repeated in India and China. Estimating inequality in pre-twentieth century societies is much harder, due to a paucity of records. Calculations have been made for the mid nineteenth century for the US and some western European countries, suggesting that they were more unequal than today. Studies looking at societies from before the nineteenth century are harder still, as census data simply did not exist in most places (the US undertook its first census in 1790, while the first census in England and Wales was taken in 1801). In Africa, such data is generally absent well into the twentieth century.

The Cape Colony provides a rare opportunity to examine wealth distribution in a pre-industrial society, as it was administered by colonial officials from first the Dutch East India Company and then the British Empire. who kept meticulous records of financial transactions, albeit largely with the aim of extracting wealth from the colony. Furthermore, Cape Town has never been affected by any major military conflict, something which as led to the destruction of records in many other parts of the world. 

Map of the Dutch Cape Colony in 1795, from George McCall Theal (1816). History of Africa south of the Zambesi - from the settlement of the Portuguese at Sofala in September 1505 to the conquest of the Cape Colony by the British in September 1795. G. Allen & Unwin Ltd, London. Internet Archive. 

Previous studies of inequality in South Africa have largely concentrated on the twentieth century, and the entrenching of disparities between racial groups by the Apartheid system, and associated political exclusion, social stratification, and control of the labour market. However, this system only entrenched divisions which were already present.

This concentration on twentieth century inequality has led to two visions of inequality in South Africa emerging, a 'Liberal' view which sees inequality as having arisen as a result of European conquest, with people becoming impoverished as a result of being dispossessed from their traditional lands, and a 'Radical' view, which views poverty as a result of a prolonged struggle over land, labour and markets. However, the debates between these two camps have generally been based around the way in which the problems should be viewed, with neither side concentrating particularly on the measurement of inequality.

The Cape Colony was founded by the Dutch East India Company (Vereenigde Oostindische Compagnie) in 1652, as a resupply station for ships on their way to Asia. It subsequently grew into a settler colony with a large agricultural economy, where at least a portion of the population enjoyed a standard of living comparable to that of Europe. This colony subsequently expanded into the African interior, with an expanding agricultural economy built upon the labour of  enslaved and Khoesan workers, and producing grain, wine, and livestock products.

Landing of Van Riebeeck at the Cape of Good Hope by Charles Davidson Bell (painted in about 1850). Wikimedia Commons.

By 1825 the Cape Colony comprised 11 districts, with more than 10 420 settler households. At the abolition of slavery in the colony in 1834, a census found over 37 000 enslaved individuals. Records of Khoesan labourers are less clear, though this appears to have increased steadily over time.

Fourie was able to access a variety of records to facilitate his study. The most important of these were annual tax censuses, which were kept by both the Dutch East India Company and British colonial officials, and many of which have been transcribed in the past decade by a team of historians at the Cape Archives. Another source of information was probate inventories (records of people's assets at the time of their death, and how these were divided amongst their heirs), which were collected by the Master of the Orphan Chamber, a public official esponsible for administering estates when individuals died intestate, left heirs under 25 or unmarried or had heirs who were untraceable. A third source of information was the Slave Emancipation Dataset, which provided detailed information about the ownership of slaves at the time of emancipation. This survey was carried out by officials appointed from London, who toured the colony documenting who owned slaves, how many slaves they owned, and estimating the value of those slaves.

A wealthy family with slaves in Cape Town in 1760. Stellenbosch Museum.

Fourie began by calculating annual Gini coefficients for the district of Stellenbosch-Drakenstein based upon annual censuses taken between 1685 and 1844. This dataset comprised 142 219 individual household records, with an average of 995 households each year. To calculate relative wealth, six assets were examined, Horses, Cattle, Sheep, wheat reaped, vines and wine.

Three trends became immediately obvious from this dataset. The first was that wealth distribution in the Cape Colony was remarkably uneven, even when only free households were included. Second is that this applies to all assets, with no asset producing a Gini coefficient less than 0.5 at any point in the record. The third was that whole there were some periods of volatility in the records, these largely reflect points at which the data collecting method was changed, rather than political events.

Fourier then combined all six asset datasets into a single bucket, using values for each item derived from the Orphan Chamber dataset. This again produced a record of remarkably uneven wealth distribution, with the Gini coefficient remaining between 0.6 and 0.75 throughout the eighteenth century, then rising further in the nineteenth century (although this was lower than for the most extreme asset types).

Looking at the share of wealth held by the wealthiest portion of the population, Fourier found that the top 1% of the population held an average of 12% of the total wealth over the eighteenth century at, but that this increased over time, with their holding on average 18% of the wealth over the period 1800-1830. This was true for smaller wealth divisions too, with the wealthiest 0.1% of the population holding an average of 2% of the total wealth in the eighteenth century and 3.7% of the total in the period 1800-1830, while the top 0.01% owned an average of 0.5% of the total wealth through the eighteenth century, and an average of 0.8% of the total wealth in the period 1800-1830. Fourier notes that because these figures reflect only agricultural assets, that they cannot be directly compared to modern statistics, but that they do demonstrate evidence for early wealth inequality.

Fourier also calculated a Gini coefficient for slave ownership, which again was very high, consistently remaining above 0.7. Adding slaves into the general basket, however, reduced the average slightly, which Fourier suggests may reflect many slaves being involved in non-taxable activities, such as domestic servitude.

However, slaves are not just assets, they are people, and members of the community. Since most slaves could be assumed to have no assets (this is not always strictly the case), Fourier first tried representing each male slave as the head of a household with zero assets. This skewed wealth distribution even further, reaching 0.92 by the end of the eighteenth century. Since slaves do have to be provided for in some way, Fourier next repeated the experiment with the assumption that slave households had resources equivalent to six sheep per year. This produced a Gini coefficient with varied between 0.89 and 0.91 over the course of the eighteenth century, comparable for the figures calculated for the slave-owning communities of the Caribbean. Thus the Cape Colony would have been one of the most unequal societies of the early modern world.

Because these records are only from a single district, Stellenbosch-Drakenstein, there remains the possibility that this district was uniquely uneven in its wealth distribution. Records were not available for all districts throughout the period, but Fourier was able to assemble a roughly coeval record set by using 1825 for the Cape District, Stellenbosch, Graaff-Reinet, Swellendam, Albany, Beaufort, George and Uitenhage; 1824 for Clanwilliam and Worcester; and 1823 for Cradock. Using this data, he created Gini coefficients for Horses, Oxen, Cattle, Sheep, wheat and wine. This record included 10 420 individual households.

The Gini coefficient remained above 0.5 for all agricultural measures in all districts, with the single exception that Albany District does not produce any wine. In all other districts, wine produced a Gini coefficient of 0.8 or higher. Distributions were most even for Horses and Oxen. Fourier suggests that Stellenbosch was at the upper end of wealth distribution inequality for two reasons; high wine production and a large number of slaves.

'Mossel Bay on the Indian Ocean' by Robert Cocking, 1818. British Library/Wikimedia Commons.

Next Fourier looked at information derived from probate records. Potentially, this could be used to examine household possessions, something absent from the taxation records, though Fourier instead chose to remain with agricultural assets, as this allowed easier comparison with records derived from other sources. Probate records were available for all districts for the entire period, with little variation in how records were made. 

Using these records, Fourier examined five agricultural assets, Cattle, Horses, Sheep, ploughs, and wagons, for the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. This produced similar results to the taxation records, consistently showing a Gini coefficient of greater than 0.6 for all assets, and from 1770 onwards, a Gini coefficient greater than 0.7, indicating a high rate of wealth inequality among settlers from the earliest days of the colony. 

The slave emancipation report records the value of each slave owned at the time of abolition, plus the compensation paid to each slave-owner, with a total of 36 417 individual records. All records come from the year 1834. Gigi coefficients constructed for slave ownership by district showed a high level of inequality, but not as great as for other assets, ranging from 0.29 for Somerset and Uitenhage to a 0.47 for Worcester. Gini coefficients for compensation for the loss of slaves ranged from 0.45 in Somerset to 0.55 in the Cape District. 

However, these figures only show inequality among slave-owning colonists, with less than 30% of the settler population at the time actually owning slaves. Once the 13 033 non-slave-owning settler households were added to the equation, the Gini coefficients shifted considerably, giving coefficients for slave-ownership between 0.49 in Stellenbosch (where slave-ownership was comon) and 0.75 in Beaufort (where slave-ownership was unusual). Coefficients for compensation were even higher, ranging from 0.83 in Somerset to 0.92 in the Cape District.

However, European settlers and their slaves were never the only people present in the Cape Colony. By the early nineteenth century a number of Khoe settlements had been incorporated into the colonial administrative system, with some, notably mission stations, having produced documentation which is now being transcribed and analysed by modern scholars. To try to represent this population, Fourier looked at three such settlements, Bethelsdorp, Swartrivier, and Groenekloof, concentrating on records from 1825.

Bethelsdorp, near Algao Bay, was founded in 1804 by the London Missionary Society, and became an important settlement where the Khoe people were able to gain some protection and autonomy within the colonial system, with a population of 425 households by 1814. However, the settlement suffered from poil soil quality, and a variety of other economic problems. 

The Swartrivier settlement in Swellendam District grew more organically, attracting pastoralist Khoe who worked as herders of labourers for European farmers, often under exploitative conditions. By 1825 Swartrivier was home to 364 households.

Groenekloof, located on the coast 55 km to the north of Cape Town, was founded by the Moravian Missionary Society in 1808, and became a haven for freed slaves and Khoesan, By 1825 the settlement comprised 108 households, practising subsistence farming, or working as labourers on settler-owned farms.

Tax records were collected for these settlements in the same way as they were for settler communities, although the number of variables per household was generally lower, probably as a reflection of these households owning fewer assets. In analysing these households, Fourier looked at five assets, Cattle, Horses, Oxen, Sheep and wheat reaped. 

Creating Gini coefficients for these assets revealed severe inequality within all three settlements. Only a single asset type (Cattle at Bethelsdorp) produced a coefficient lower than 0.75, and that was 0.72. The distribution of many assets approached near perfect inequality (i.e. the situation where one person owns all of the asset). For example, only ten families owned sheep in Bethelsdorp and only one family owned Sheep in Groenekloof. Thus, inequality among the Khoe was typically more severe than among European settlers. Including this group with the general population pushed inequality even further, due to the greater wealth typically held by settler households. This led to a Gini coefficient for Cattle ownership of 0.92, and measures for Horses, Oxen and wheat all in excess of 0.77.

Korah/Koranna preparing to move. Samuel Daniell, 1831. William Fehr Collection/Iziko Museums of South Africa.

Fourier's findings reflect severe inequality (generally interpreted as a Gini coefficient of greater than 0.6) for all assets, and both within and between communities, throughout the history of the Cape Colony. Such inequality had clearly arisen long before the beginning of the twentieth century. While comparing historic income and wealth to their modern equivalents is notoriously problematic, within-period comparisons can determine the distribution of assets, and therefore how equal or unequal societies were.

See also...

Sunday, 31 August 2025

Little Foot.

In the late nineteen thirties, palaeontologist Robert Broom discovered a series of Hominin skeletons in a cave system in Sterkfontain, South Africa. These, he assigned to the genus Australopithecus, which had been described in 1925 by Raymond Dart, suggesting that he had found a second species in the same genus. At the time, these discoveries did not receive a great deal of attention from the international scientific community. The cave deposits at Sterkfontain were estimated by Broom to be Late Pleistocene in age. This made Broom's material much younger than Dart's and contemporary with modern Human remains from many parts of the world, which meant that, while interesting, Broom's new 'Ape-man' could not be ancestral to modern Humans.

More locally, however, the discoveries caused considerable interest, leading many amateur fossil hunters to begin exploring the Sterkfontain cave system. One of these was Helmut Kurt Silberberg, a Johannesburg art dealer and antiquarian with an interest in prehistory. In 1942, Silberberg's explorations led to the discovery of a small cave with numerous bones embedded in the walls. Unfortunately, the rock in which the bones were embedded was extremely hard (more so than the bone) making excavation difficult. Silberberg paid a local man to hammer free a chunk of rock, during which process several bones were broken, displeasing Silberberg. When the bones in the rock were examined, they were found to belong to a Hyena and a Baboon. 

Discouraged by these findings, Silberberg lost interest in the work, giving his specimens to Broom, and moving onto other projects. While the fossils were not interesting to Silberberg, the material proved to be much more useful to Broom, who recognised the Hyena as a member of the genus Lycyaena, which was otherwise known from the Early Pliocene of Europe and India. Even if this South African specimen was younger than other fossil Hyenas assigned to the genus, it was unlikely to be Late Pleistocene in age. This caused him to re-evaluate the age of the cave system using Mammal fossils to establish an age sequence, which proved that his Australopithecus fossils were much older, and therefore much more significant, than he had originally realised. Broom named the Hyena fossil Lycyaena silberbergi (a name which is no longer used) and the cave where it was found was eventually named Silberberg Grotto.

In 1966, palaeoanthropologists Philip Tobias and Alun Hughs began a new series of excavations at the Sterkfontein Caves, working methodically through the cave system from west to east, and uncovering several new specimens, albeit mostly fragmentary. In 1978 they revisited Silberberg Grotto, removing large sample of breccia, which was cleaned by technicians at the site to recover a larger amount of fossil material, most of which was moved to the University of the Witwatersrand, while some remained in storage at Sterkfontein.

From left to right, Raymond Dart, Alun Hughes, and Phillip Tobias at Witwatersrand University in the mid-1970s. Clarke & Kramer (2012).

In 1992 Tobias' team returned to Silberberg Grotto, this time employing two mining engineers, John Cruise and Dusty van Rooyen, to blast away a section of the fossil-rich wall of the cave. Analysis of the material recovered by this process in 1994 by palaeoanthropologist Ronald Clarke revealed something surprising. The rocks had produced numerous bones associated with Carnivores and Monkeys, but for some reason almost no Bovids (usually the most abundant Mammals in South African deposits). This led him to return to the material stored at Witwatersrand, which he also analysed for the proportions of different Mammal groups. 

While examining this material, Clarke discovered what appeared to be the talus, navicular, medial cuneiform and proximal half of the first metatarsal of an unknown Hominin. This was surprising for two reasons. Firstly, the material had been examined previously by specialists palaeoanthropologists looking for exactly this sort of material, and secondly because the Silberberg Grotto had by this time been identified as somewhat older than the previous Hominin-producing deposits at Sterkfontein, implying any fossil Hominin found here could be the oldest yet identified specimen from the cave system. In addition to these four bones, Clarke found what appeared to be a badly damaged lateral cuneiform from the right foot, and a fragment of a possible Hominid calcaneum.

This material suggested a small Hominin, capable of standing upright like a Human, but still retaining an disposable big toe like an Ape, which suggested that at least some of its time was still spent within the trees. This specimen was given the official designation StW 573, but quickly became known as 'Little Foot'.

In 1997 Clarke discovered a box labelled 'D18 Cercopithecoids' (Old World Monkeys), which when inspected was found to also contain material labelled 'D20 Cercopithecoids'. Since D20 implied the layer of material exposed at Silberberg Grotto, and Clarke was interested in the fauna of this cave, he took down this box to inspect its contents. Within this material he found a Hominid intermediate cuneiform, which he found fit with the lateral cuneiform associated with Little Foot. Along with this was the left lateral cuneiform, the proximal end of the left second metatarsal and the left distal fibula. A subsequent search of related material uncovered the disto-medial portion of a Hominid tibia. This did not fit exactly with the Little Foot talus, but was close enough that, once the damage to the material was taken into account, Clarke considered it likely to have come from the same individual.

This tibia had a break across its shaft consistent with the sort of damage caused by mine blasting, Clarke next turned to the material stored at Sterkfontein. Here, in a bag of material labelled as Bovid tibiae, he found another Hominid tibia, which this time fit perfectly with the left talus of StW 573, leading him to realise that the previously discovered tibia was in fact from the right leg. Further inspection of this material also produced a second piece of cuneiform, which fit together with the one from the original Little Foot material, giving a complete bone. This had a bowl-like surface on its articular surface with the cuboid bone, indicating that these bones still articulated (could be moved relative to one-another), as in Chimpanzees, and unlike the condition seen in Modern Humans, where the two are immobilised by a keel-and-socket arrangement, which gives more stability when walking and running upright.

This gave Clarke a collection of twelve bones from the feet and lower legs of a single Hominin, including the left tibia and fibula, which joined to an articulated set of eight foot and ankle bones, and the distal fragment of a right tibia and right lateral cuneiform.

Convinced that more material might still be found in Silberberg Grotto, Clarke prepared a cast of the distal fragment of the right tibia of StW 573, which he gave to two perpetrators based at Sterkfontein, Nkwane Molefe and Stephen Motsumi. Molefe and Motsumi then searched the area exposed by blasting within Silberberg Grotto, looking for an exposed cross section of bone which would fit this cast. 

Clarke was not optimistic that this approach would work. The various excavations had turned the grotto into a cavern of some size, with exposed breccia on the walls, floor and ceiling, all of which might contain the matching bone fragment - if it was there at all. As if this was not difficult enough, there was neither natural light nor a rigged lighting system within the cave, forcing the two investigators to search using hand-held torches. 

After two days Molefe and Motsumi reported finding a bone embedded in a talus slope at the western end of the grotto, which was a perfect match for the cast given to them by Clarke. This was unexpected, as this was not the area where Cruise and van Rooyen had carried out their blasting, but an older area of excavations where blasting had been carried out by commercial miners extracting limestone for use in the construction industry, an operation which had stopped 65 years before. Furthermore, a second section of bone could be seen to the left of this bone, which turned out to be a perfect match for the broken left tibia.

Ronald Clarke, Stephen Motsumi and Nkwane Molefe. Kathleen Kuman/Mail & Guardian.

Following this discovery, Clarke, Molefe, and Motsumi began excavating the site using hand tools, taking almost a year to uncover the left tibia shaft and the distal ends with lower shafts of the left and right femurs. After which, however, the material apparently stopped, until Motsumi hammered away a section of travertine (dense limestone deposited by hot springs) higher up the slope exposing more breccia, and the distal and of a Hominid humerus and mandible. The skeleton had apparently been entombed in rock, broken in half by an ancient rockfall, and covered by travertine from an ancient hot spring, before eventually being exposed by limestone miners some time in the early twentieth century.

In the following months, and eventually years, the skull, left forearm, left hand, pelvis, ribs, vertebrae, humerus, and most of the lower limb bones were extracted. The final skeleton was 90% complete, the most complete non-Human Hominin skeleton ever recovered. For comparison, the famous Lucy (or Dink'inesh) skeleton AL 288-1, considered to be the most complete specimen of Australopithecus afarensis, is only 40% complete.

The complete skeleton of StW 573, Little Foot.  Paul John Myburgh/ University of the Witwatersrand.

The Sterkfontein cave system, now part of the Maropeng Cradle of Humankind World Heritage Site, are a karstic cave system on the south side of the Bloubank River, about 50 km to the northwest of Johannesburg. Karstic cave systems form as water percolates through limestones, dissolving some of the mineral to create voids. This is a complex process, as cave systems form, are enlarge by the hollowing-out of water erosion, then collapse bringing sediments from above down to lower levels and often redirecting the water flow which caused the hollowing out. Furthermore, the limestone dissolved in one place is typically re-deposited in another, as travertines or flowstones. All of this makes establishing timelines for the karstic deposits extremely complicated.

Sterkfontein Caves began to form about six million years ago, towards the end of the Miocene. Throughout much of the intervening time the local environment has been a mosaic of grasslands, woodlands, and lakes, albeit with warmer, wetter phases, and cooler, dryer phases. At least five different Hominin species have been found within the caves, some of whom appear to have sought shelter within cave systems, others to have been dragged their for consumption by cave-dwelling carnivores, while others appear to have fallen into sinkholes.

Skeleton StW 573, or Little Foot, was found closely associated with a large Baboon (an animal quite capable of predating a small Hominin), but does not show any signs of having been consumed. Rather, it seems to have fallen face-down into a shallow puddle of water within a sinkhole. Possibly the Hominin and Baboon fell together following a struggle, but this is guesswork we will never be able to prove. The chamber where it was found contained Pliocene Hyenas, and was directly below the chamber which produced Bloom's most famous Australopithecus specimen, Mrs. Ples (STS 5), and therefore must be older than that specimen.

In 1978, geomorphologist Timothy Cooper was part of the team led by Tobias and Hughes which re-examined the Silberberg Grotto. He established that the chamber had formed as a cone-shaped void, the walls of which had then been covered by flowstone (dissolved and then re-deposited limestone), before an opening had reached the surface, forming a sinkhole into which surface sediments, and various Animals now preserved as fossils, had fallen, filling in the cone. These sediments were then covered by a second flowstone deposit. The sediments within this cone were thought to be about 2.8 million years old (Late Pliocene) on the basis of the fossil fauna they contained, implying a similar age for Little Foot. 

However, Molefe and Motsumi had established that Little Foot had in fact come from below the lower flowstone deposit, with only a small portion displaced into the accessible sediments by an ancient rockfall and the actions of early twentieth century miners. Various attempts have been made to date this flowstone deposit, including cosmogenic uranium-lead series nuclide dating, palaeomagnatism. These studies produced dates between 4 million years and 1.07 million years ago, although most fell into the range between 2.8 and 2.2 million years ago. However, subsequent studies also established that the flowstone itself contained pockets of younger, redeposited material, making all dating of this layer suspect.

Cosmogenic aluminium²⁶ and beryllium¹⁰ dating works because both aluminium²⁶ and beryllium¹⁰ are produced in quartz exposed to cosmic rays (i.e. on the surface) at a steady rate, producing a ration of 6.75 aluminium²⁶ to 1.0 beryllium¹⁰. Once the quartz is buried no more of either radioisotope is formed. Since the half-life of aluminium²⁶ is roughly half that of beryllium¹⁰, over time the ratio between the two radioisotopes will change, enabling the precise measurement of both how long a piece of quartz was exposed on the surface, and how long ago this happened. In April 2015 a study led by Darryl Granger of Purdue University produced a date for the sediments in which StW 573 was directly lying, based upon cosmogenic aluminium²⁶ and beryllium¹⁰, yielding an age of 3.67 million years before the present (equivalent to the dates for early Australopithecus afarensis specimens from East Africa. 

Darryl Granger. Lena Kovalenko/Purdue University.

This also makes StW 573 the oldest Hominin fossil discovered in South Africa, as well as the most complete pre-Human Hominin fossil ever found. It also predates the oldest stone tools in South Africa by over a million years, and the oldest known stone tools anywhere by over 300 000 years, suggesting that it came from a population which did not yet have this technology. 

Studies of Little Foot have suggested that she was female, and stood about 1.20-1.30 m tall, with longer legs than arms (similar to modern Humans, but unlike Chimpanzees). She had an 'S' shaped collarbone, which is a more Human-like trait, and but the shape of her pectoral girdle and shoulder blades, suggest that she was comfortable moving in trees suspended by her arms. The structure of its foot suggests that it was able to walk in an erect manner, similar to modern Humans, but still had an opposable big toe, implying it was still a comfortable climber (Pliocene Hominins are in general thought to have been woodland species, with the preference for open grasslands emerging in the Pleistocene when a cooler, dryer climate led to the retreat of forests and expansion of grasslands). 

This fits well with the environment in which her remains were found. While the Silberberg Grotto produced the remains of some terrestrial Animals, such as Antelope and Hyenas, the majority of the fossils are of Animals associated with an arboreal lifestyle, such as small Monkeys and Felids. Such Animals might have climbed down into the sinkhole in order to obtain water and become trapped, or possibly have fallen directly from trees into the hole - in Little Foot's case, possibly while trying to escape from a large Baboon.

Surprisingly, despite the completeness and significance of Little Foot, she has never been assigned to a specific species. She was referred to by Ronald Clarke as possibly a specimen of Australopithecus prometheus. However, this species name is now considered to be invalid; it was used by Raymond Dart to refer to a partial occipital bone (part of the back of the skull) from Makapansgat, but this has now been assessed as a specimen of Australopithecus africanus, a species common in South Africa from about 3.3 to about 2.1 million years ago. However, Little Foot is not generally accepted as belonging to Australopithecus africanus, which it predates as well as differing from in its brain capacity (smaller in Little Foot) and shoulder arrangements (more Ape-like in Australopithecus africanus). Nor does she conform to Australopithecus afarensis, a species whose time range she overlaps, but which is not found in Southern Africa. 

Thus Little Foot appears to be an otherwise entirely unknown species of Australopithecus from South Africa, with an arboreal lifestyle and no use of stone tools. This is not completely surprising, as species such as Australopithecus africanus and Australopithecus afarensis are clearly already some way removed from their closest Ape relatives. and species which live in trees seldom have good (if any) fossil records.

See also...